.jpg?auto=compress&auto=format)
House Favorites
Hand Tossed Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$12.00
Cauliflower Crust Pizza
$16.00
Specialty Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Roma tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, chopped garlic & fresh made marinara finished with fresh basil, parmesan & EVOO drizzle.
$16.00
5 Boroughs Pizza
A blend of 5 delicious cheeses! Mozzarella, parmesan, asiago, feta & provolone.
$16.00
Whitestone Bridge Pizza
Ricotta, fresh mozzarella & garlic finished with parmesan & EVOO drizzle.
$16.00
Pizza Caprese
Fresh Mozzarella, tomatoes, cracked black pepper and basil with EVOO & balsamic glaze.
$16.00
Boogey Down Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Crispy chicken, blue cheese & franks red hot sauce topped with mozzarella.
$16.00
Blazin BBQ Chicken Pizza
Grilled chicken, onion, jalapenos, bacon, & sweet baby rays topped with mozzarella and provolone.
$16.00
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Crispy chicken, bacon, & ranch topped with mozzarella.
$16.00
Chicken Parmigiana Pizza
Crispy chicken topped with fresh garlic and our homemade marinara sauce!
$17.00
Loaded Pizza
Nassau Knot Pizza
Our pizza with fresh made garlic knots baked on to the crust & served with our fresh made marinara.
$17.00
North Morris Ave Pizza
Crispy eggplant, ricotta cheese, capers, sundried tomatoes, & chopped garlic finished with fresh basil, parmesan & EVOO.
$17.00
Strong Island Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, ham & bacon.
$17.00
Godfather Pizza
Pepperoni, crispy chicken, chopped garlic, ricotta cheese & jalapenos finished with red chili flakes.
$17.00
Fuggedaboutit Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, black olives & onion.
$17.00
Pesto Perfecto Pizza
Crispy chicken, mushrooms, onions & ricotta cheese finished with fresh basil pesto & red chili flakes.
$17.00
Franklin Square Pizza
Suffolk County Sicilian Pizza
Traditional thick square pizza.
$21.00
Grandma Sadie Pizza
Traditional thick square thin crust square style pizza with fresh crushed pomodoro grandma's sauce, basil & mozzarella.
$19.00
Brooklyn Pizza
First comes the mozzarella, then the sauce on top of a thick square pizza finished with EVOO and parmesan.
$21.00
Pizza By The Slice
Cheese Pizza Slice
$5.00
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
$6.00
Monday Specials
1 Large Cheese Pizza
$15.00
Tuesday Specials
Medium Cheese Pizza Tuesday Special
$12.00
Large Cheese Pizza and Large House Salad
$25.00
Thursday Specials
Large Cheese Pizza & Large House Salad - Thursday Special
$25.00
Thursday Special
$32.00
Quick Eats
French Fries
$8.50
Fried Pickles
$9.50
Fried Mushrooms
$9.50
Fried “Mooozadel”
Breaded and fried golden mozzarella served with fresh made marinara.
$9.00
Garlic Knots
Served with fresh made marinara.
$8.00
Mama’s Baked Meatballs
Meatballs Mama’s way covered in fresh made marinara & mozzarella.
$10.00
Italian Garlic Cheese Bread
Sliced Italian bread with garlic oil spread & oregano topped with mozzarella.
$8.00
Cauliflower Wings
Battered and fried cauliflower florets tossed in your choice of sauce.
$11.00
“Bada Bing” Wings
Traditional crispy fried bone-in wings.
$11.00
Boneless Wings
Crispy fried boneless wings.
$11.00
Arancini Rice Ball
Fried Arancini Rice Ball with ground beef, peas and melted mozzarella cheese
$5.00
Philly Rice Ball
$5.00
Buffalo Chicken Eggroll
2 buffalo chicken eggrolls
$6.00
Salads
Long Island House Salad
Fresh romaine, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, black olives & croutons.
$13.00
Caesar Salad
Fresh romaine lettuce, shaved parmesan & croutons.
$12.00
Caprese Salad
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes & basil drizzled with EVOO & balsamic glaze.
$14.00
Greek Salad
Fresh romaine, tomatoes, onion, kalamata olives, banana peppers & feta cheese.
$14.00
Papa Joe’s Antipasto Salad
Fresh romaine topped with pepperoni, ham, salami, provolone, roasted red peppers, artichoke hearts, black & green olives.
$15.00
Calzones & Stromboli
Calzone
Stuffed with ricotta, parmesan & mozzarella & finished with garlic oil. Served with fresh made marinara.
$13.00
Stromboli
Stuffed with mozzarella & finished with garlic oil. Served with fresh made marinara.
$11.00
Heroes
Chicken Parmesan Hero
$11.00
Eggplant Parmesan Hero
$11.00
Meatball Parmesan Hero
$11.00
Great Bambino Hero
Sliced genoa salami, pepperoni, capicola, & provolone topped with shredded lettuce, onion, tomatoes, oil, vinegar, & oregano.
$13.00
Philly Cheese Steak Hero
Chopped ribeye, mushrooms, peppers, onions, cheese sauce, & provolone.
$13.00
Desserts
Cannoli
$4.00
Chocolate Cannoli
$5.00
NY High-Rise Cheesecake
$8.00
Limoncello Mascarpone Cake
$8.00
Layer Chocolate Dream Cake
$9.00
Colossal Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake
$8.00
Italian ice
$3.00
Tiramisu
$8.00
Key Lime Pie
$7.00
Beverages
Soda
$2.90
2 liter Soda
$3.99
Bottle Water
$2.00
2 liter diet pepsi
$3.99
Lunch Specials
One Pizza Slice Lunch Special
$5.00
Rice Balls Lunch Special
$5.00
One Pizza Slice & Drink Lunch Special
$7.00
Two Pizza Slice & Drink Lunch Special
$12.00
Pepperoni Pin Wheel
$5.00
Single Garlic knot
1 garlic knot
$1.75
Spinach Rice Ball
$5.00
Buffalo chicken pin wheel
$5.00
Garlic sticks (2)
$1.75
Sides
Side of Ranch
$0.50
Side of blue cheese
$0.50
Side of Marinara sauce
$0.50
Arancini Rice Ball
$5.00
Spinach Rice Ball
$5.00
Wednesday Special
6 Garlic Knots & Large Cheese Pizza
$23.00
Large Pizza Bada Bing + 6 Wings Wednesday Special
$25.00
Long Island New York Pizza
In the mood for something delicious? Enjoy the best pizza Cape Coral has to offer. Long Island New York Pizza remains one of the most popular in Cape Coral. Give them a try and see what makes them such a favorite. You'll find more than just pizza at the top restaurants in Cape Coral. Try some of the local top dishes for a treat. Try Chicken Parmigiana Pizza and see what all the fuss is about. This local classic has created an enviable reputation over the years. Bulk up your meal with fried “mooozadel”. It's the best way to make sure you don't go away hungry. Long Island New York Pizza has been a Slice partner for years, providing delivery and takeout in the community. Curbside pickup at Long Island New York Pizza makes things easy. Place an order, and it'll be ready for you to pick up at your convenience. Long Island New York Pizza accepts credit cards. That makes it easy to get your pizza sooner.
Full Hours